Critique my logo please

Anonymous87's picture

Designed a handwritten signature logo for a digital photographic artist. His interests lies in surrealism, digital art, and photography.

Anonymous87's picture

Oops! Here it is:

aluminum's picture

Is that the actual signature? Right now it looks a bit like a bad auto-trace.

Anonymous87's picture

No it's not the actual signature, should've been more clear. We took the original signature and played with the lines a bit.

Joshua Langman's picture

Sorry, but it looks very unprofessional. Lines too thin, widths too uneven, doesn't hold together. It does look like autotrace.

JamesM's picture

Difficult to read and not very attractive.

Note that a signature logo doesn't have to be the person's real signature; it fact due to identity theft it's probably not a good idea. Here's Walt Disney's real signature and his logo signature:

Anonymous87's picture

Thanks, JamesM, for your constructive criticism. I'm having a hard time with this because the person I working on this logo for doesn't want to take the time to create a font out of his signature, and isn't a fan of many signature fonts. I think this logo is a bust and should start fresh with another idea.

Joshua Langman's picture

That sounds like probably a good idea, especially if the client isn't on board with the idea. Good luck!

Syndicate content Syndicate content