Serif Church Sign Lettering

Classification: 

This is some lettering for a church sign. It was installed many years ago, and over time, they lost some of the letters. They replaced them with a different font, but decided they wanted to revert back to this one. However, nobody knows what font it is.
I’m having trouble finding a font that matches the “R” and the numbers.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!

In the second picture, it's the serif font, not the sans serif numbers on the right.

Comments

The letters are very small on your samples and can't be sure but it looks like [[http://www.findmyfont.com/index.php/fonts/font-preview?fset=Bitstream&ff...|Americana (Extra Bold Condensed)]] from Bitstream
or a manually compressed Americana (Extra Bold) from Adobe, Linotype, URW++