Your Feedback is Needed

butterworth
12.Apr.2007 8.57am
butterworth's picture

I’m working on a new poster for my graphic design business and would appreciate your feedback on the composition I have created. Thank you in advance for your thoughtful comments :)

AttachmentSize
WhoRules.jpg193.05 KB


sch2525
12.Apr.2007 9.12am
sch2525's picture

No offense, but I can’t tell if you’re kidding or not.


seventy7
12.Apr.2007 9.14am
seventy7's picture

I agree. Your fine art is very nice. Graphic design—not so much. Which is why I’m confused.

I’m starting to wonder if you’re here to mock graphic designers.


dezcom
12.Apr.2007 9.15am
dezcom's picture

LOL!!!
I think you left out a few Photoshop filters :-)

ChrisL


seventy7
12.Apr.2007 9.16am
seventy7's picture

Ok, so it’s definitely a joke of some sort. The poster is very funny and i’m sure you not trying to be mocking.


Asvetic
12.Apr.2007 9.20am
Asvetic's picture

Genius, Pure Genius!

You forgot the Lens Flare.


butterworth
12.Apr.2007 9.27am
butterworth's picture

Here’s an alternate version.

:)


Linda Cunningham
12.Apr.2007 9.27am
Linda Cunningham's picture

I’m gob-smacked. Utterly.


sch2525
12.Apr.2007 9.28am
sch2525's picture

Oh thank God. It took me a good 10 minutes to figure out if I should even comment or not. Then another 10 to think of what to say - this is the one time I’ve been left speechless!

Your fine art is very nice.

I think the word I would use is cool ;)

EDIT: Your second version looks like it needs a little more pizzazz.


pattyfab
12.Apr.2007 9.29am
pattyfab's picture

I have to ask - couldn’t you manage to work in Comic Sans somehow?

I should add that v.2 is a vast improvement. I LOVE Zapf Chancery all caps.


kuroneko
12.Apr.2007 9.31am
kuroneko's picture

the next level is to do the same in word art!


Asvetic
12.Apr.2007 9.32am
Asvetic's picture

I once did a project entirely in MS Paint... my professor was bemused.


Linda Cunningham
12.Apr.2007 9.35am
Linda Cunningham's picture

I had a client once hand me a draft presentation for a Fortune 500 company that used Balloon and Comic Sans, and had every letter a different colour, and he couldn’t figure out why I went into hysterical laughter. ;-)


kuroneko
12.Apr.2007 9.36am
kuroneko's picture

why not make a MS Paint / Word Art / Photoshop Filters contest ?


Linda Cunningham
12.Apr.2007 9.40am
Linda Cunningham's picture

Probably because there are too many candidates to choose from!


ill sans
12.Apr.2007 9.41am
ill sans's picture

This deserves a nomination for most obvious in the humour section! You do lose points for not using either Comic Sans or Zapf Chancery in all caps though (good call, Patty) however.
Aside from a few filters left untouched, you still make a great chance of winning this round!


kuroneko
12.Apr.2007 9.49am
kuroneko's picture

comic sans forever


dezcom
12.Apr.2007 10.07am
dezcom's picture

Ahhhh, Mr Butterworth, now that is MUCH better :-)

ChrisL


Miss Tiffany
12.Apr.2007 10.31am
Miss Tiffany's picture

Craig, I really think it is missing something. Have you tried using something metallic and/or reflective?


Asvetic
12.Apr.2007 10.37am
Asvetic's picture

Shouldn’t it be: GRAPHICAL DESIGNS MASTER!


butterworth
12.Apr.2007 11.02am
butterworth's picture

If only there was some way to add a techno soundtrack in photoshop... Until that day comic sans and a metallic finish will do.

Thanks for the comments.

Craig


Linda Cunningham
12.Apr.2007 11.32am
Linda Cunningham's picture

Well, you could add a musical clip if you ported it into Acrobat.... ;-)


ben_archer
16.Apr.2007 1.36am
ben_archer's picture

Craig, have you shown it to the guy who posted here recently looking for graphic clichés and overused lame tricks ?

I dunno why, but that thread seemingly disappeared without trace...

Any chance you could come and run a PhotoShop 101 course for us?


jupiterboy
16.Apr.2007 8.47am
jupiterboy's picture

I quit.


pattyfab
16.Apr.2007 8.59am
pattyfab's picture

Ben, I wondered the same thing. It didn’t seem too flame-y or anything.


Miss Tiffany
16.Apr.2007 9.43am
Miss Tiffany's picture

Which thread disappeared?


pattyfab
16.Apr.2007 10.20am
pattyfab's picture

Oh there was a thread started by some guy collecting overused design cliches. It was either in Design or General Discussions. It was kind of funny.


dezcom
16.Apr.2007 10.47am
dezcom's picture

It was Kuroneko and he linked to it from this thread. Perhaps he removed it?

ChrisL


andrew_baker
16.Apr.2007 2.26pm
andrew_baker's picture

Craig, do you also make time travel gadgets by any chance?


dezcom
16.Apr.2007 2.51pm
dezcom's picture

LOL!!!

I think he sells used Delorian parts though :-)

ChrisL


jupiterboy
16.Apr.2007 3.50pm
jupiterboy's picture

And how’s the Mrs.? Up to no good as usual I hear.

http://www.theonion.com/content/node/32232