Though it was just recently designed, the Font Bureau’s Escrow is based on a similar style and its weights and size (Display and Text) variations might be the best option here.

Escrow’s a good idea, Stephen. Thanks. Though I wish i good find something that had a bit more of a vintage flavor to it ...

I hear you. More vintage Scotches:

Modern Extended
Monotype Modern
DeVinne and DeVinne Text
Scotch Roman
Modern No. 20
Century Expanded

Thanks for the lovely list! Lots to think about.

Very much appreciated.