Why can't people educate themselves about ampersands?

aszszelp
13.May.2008 4.22am
aszszelp's picture

Using c_t-ligature instead of an ampersand. Come on! (at “tips & examples” under query input field)

(powerset.com)

[minor edit]



Jos Buivenga
13.May.2008 5.18am
Jos Buivenga's picture

It’s very small ... but to me it looks like Delicious (with the proper ampersand).


James Puckett
13.May.2008 5.34am
James Puckett's picture

Gotta love those gallic ampersands! YUM!


Jos Buivenga
13.May.2008 5.44am
Jos Buivenga's picture


charles_e
13.May.2008 5.48am
charles_e's picture

“Why can’t people educate themselves about glyphs?”

First of all, if you are talking about the ct-ligature in general, and the ampersand in general, they are not “glyphs” but “characters.” If you are talking about, say, the Garamond Premier Pro ct-ligature and ampersand, those are glyphs.


eliason
13.May.2008 7.21am
eliason's picture

J0s ßuivenga is r¡ght!


James Puckett
13.May.2008 7.49am
James Puckett's picture

You design type AND play MMOs AND decorate your avatar with your ampersand? Jos, you are the nerd KING!


Jos Buivenga
13.May.2008 8.05am
Jos Buivenga's picture

:-)

BTW Have I already mentioned the eternal pleasure I get out of sleeping upside down in my wardrobe closet (a bit like a giant bat)?


aszszelp
13.May.2008 8.45am
aszszelp's picture

I must admit, I am baffled. I know that style of ampersands, that’s why I thought they mixed it up with the ct-lig. However, for me that glyph (which is in that particular font indeed the ampersand) for me looks more like a ct-lig than a script-capital-e_t-ligature formed ampersand.

Still nice to learn (and not to be scorned immediately for being in this case stupidly mistaken). I like this community. :-)


oprion
13.May.2008 9.32am
oprion's picture

Don’t forger this wonderful contraption: 8c
_____________________________________________
Personal Art and Design Portal of Ivan Gulkov
www.ivangdesign.com


canderson
13.May.2008 9.36am
canderson's picture

At that size, it actually looks more like “Et” to me than a typical ampersand. There probably are ampersands that look much like the c_t lig.


William Berkson
13.May.2008 10.42am
William Berkson's picture

Personally, I think it’s a mistake to make the ampersand look too much like “Et,” the latin word for “and,” from which it derives. Recently a number of fonts have done it, but to me it’s distracting. The most of the old ampersands are notable in not ’reading’ as “et,” even though you can figure how they “got here from there” when you inspect them.


canderson
13.May.2008 12.14pm
canderson's picture

Good point. You don’t want people saying “et” when they read an ampersand. This may be a bit off topic, but does anyone know of an ampersand that uses shapes from a, n, and d? I guess that would be sort-of English only, and probably something lots of people would find distracting.


concrete
13.May.2008 1.34pm
concrete's picture

’Et’ vs ’ct’ vs the ’8x’ immm either-way I like Delicious ’Et’ ampersand certainly beats the ’8x’ or is it ’8c’ though nothing really beats the good old ’and’

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ampersand


Nick Shinn
13.May.2008 3.17pm
Nick Shinn's picture

I like to see “&c.” used in lieu of “etc.”


Oisín
13.May.2008 5.54pm
Oisín's picture

You’re not the only one, Nick. I rarely use it myself (since I tend to spell it out as ‘et cetera’), but I do like it.

In my normal handwriting, I also write my ampersands as an Ɛ with a vertical line through it (like a ‘|’, but with higher ascender and lower descender), a self-invented evolvement of the Et ampersand.


JCSalomon
13.May.2008 10.15pm
JCSalomon's picture

 The “&c.” abbreviation for “et cetera” looks good with almost every style of ampersand other than the G-clef one. And it usually needs an italic c.
—Joel


eliason
13.May.2008 10.36pm
eliason's picture

And if you’re going old-school with the “&c”s, I hope you occasionally double them up for effect!


aszszelp
14.May.2008 1.50am
aszszelp's picture

Actually, when etc. is at the end of a sentence or even more, at the end of a paragraph, I do double it up — in speech.


whoislewis
14.May.2008 4.19am
whoislewis's picture

Hey guys, i’m brand spankin’ new! to the forum and like to point out an article i ran up against in the light of the discussion upstairs..
www.typography.com


joeclark
14.May.2008 8.59am
joeclark's picture

This seems to be a classic case of a correction’s being itself incorrect. The sample shown is clearly the Rotis Et ampersand.


Joe Clark
http://joeclark.org/


Jos Buivenga
14.May.2008 9.14am
Jos Buivenga's picture

To me this seems to be a classic case of an incorrect correction on a correction that itself is correct.


Ehague
14.May.2008 11.02am
Ehague's picture

I think that the ampersand is one of those characters that has so many half-accepted forms that it has a wider spectrum of acceptable variations (with regard to basic legibility) than most characters. Maybe I’m off the mark, but I feel as if nearly any funky, pretzelish symbol interposed between two words will be read as “and.”

Maybe lowercase g shares this distinction, too, to an extent.


eliason
14.May.2008 11.18am
eliason's picture

feel as if nearly any funky, pretzelish symbol interposed between two words will be read as “and.”

My favorite from this thread:


Pedro Leal
14.May.2008 5.25pm
Pedro Leal's picture

In Portuguese the word and is represented by the letter “e” so the & is rarely used as an alternative. Even so i use it as much as possible, mainly when i write &c.
I also must say that, personally, i don’t see any problem when the et ligature is really obvious... but then again Portuguese words will always have a close connection to their Latin predecessors. Et works perfectly on French as well, so i can see why some designers are making this ligature more obvious. I do understand that in English reading “et” may come out confusing but then again, in my opinion, the & has it’s own reading!

Sorry, if this post got confusing... is getting late here and I’m just too sleepy!


aszszelp
15.May.2008 6.51am
aszszelp's picture

Yeah, you would’nt use “&” much in languagees with single-lettered words for “and” like Portugues, Spanish, Italian, Russian...


AGL
15.May.2008 8.32am
AGL's picture

Don’t forget the

Y


Chipman223
15.May.2008 10.47am
Chipman223's picture

Hey, they still spelled “tips” and “facts” with a “z,” maybe that deserves some scolding.


Pedro Leal
15.May.2008 2.13pm
Pedro Leal's picture

Don´t forget the W and the K as well.


aszszelp
16.May.2008 2.50am
aszszelp's picture

I think they use the Z for branding.


Chipman223
16.May.2008 5.35am
Chipman223's picture

I think they use the Z for branding.
Rappers do the same, but it still looks/sounds ridiculous. I think that’s for another post though.


AGL
16.May.2008 6.07am
AGL's picture

As in

Prestige Tatore y Hijos, sarl


elliot100
16.May.2008 6.47am
elliot100's picture

Personally, I think it’s a mistake to make the ampersand look too much like “Et,” the latin word for “and,” from which it derives. Recently a number of fonts have done it, but to me it’s distracting...

Isn’t this rather undermined by your choice of profile image...?

Additionally, the single straight quote in place of the apostrophe in this thread title is somewhat ironic.


Joe Pemberton
16.May.2008 7.44am
Joe Pemberton's picture

An excerpt has been broadcast to the outside world via Twitter: http://twitter.com/Typophile


William Berkson
16.May.2008 9.13am
William Berkson's picture

>Isn’t this rather undermined by your choice of profile image...?

I don’t think so. The E in the Caslon italic ampersand (in this case my version) is readable, but that swashy curly stuff on the right doesn’t “read” as a “t”. I think only if you know that the ampersand is derived from “et”, which most people don’t, would you puzzle out that the right part evolved from a “t”.


eliason
16.May.2008 9.23am
eliason's picture

You don’t think it’s a mistake to make it look too much like a swash E, then?


William Berkson
16.May.2008 9.45am
William Berkson's picture

Honestly, it’s a matter of what people are accustomed to seeing. So I don’t think people have a problem with the evident E in the Caslon (and some other old style) italics. The symbol as a whole doesn’t read as any word, and that I think is helpful. By the way, it was interesting to me that when I worked on my swash italic E, I couldn’t take it from the ampersand. I tried it and it wouldn’t work. I did use a curly E but had to change the form pretty completely. (Caslon himself never did a swash E. All those are Victorian and later.)