I also was curious to how the book “Grid Systems in Graphic Design” rates against “Making and Breaking the Grid” for learning and better understanding the art of grids?

I would like to know what you guys think of those books too. The Muller Brockman one is a lot more expensive and a lot older I know. Is there any others that are good?

I do use this technique for book layout
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canons_of_page_construction

but magazine, I am curious to how many columns to use, there always seem to be a lot more column use for magazine layout.

Monsta - in response to your question, from the little formal theory and historic examples I know of grids, I think it is a visual thing. By developing a rock-solid grid for your magazine this will give it a visual hierarchy and consistency throughout.
In your posted example they use many columns so they can alter the layout depending on what the content is. In the context of a magazine or similar publication you ideally would establish a width for your minimum text column and adding in gutters and margins, work that into a full two-page spread. In certain layouts you may then decide to run text over 2 columns for a feature or more for heads etc.

Having a template like this will give you the freedom to chop and change your layouts to suit the amount of copy, open pages, ads, etc.

Hope that makes sense.

when a grid system has 8-12 columns it is giving the designer a more versatile way of laying out the design. It is also usually used when you have more complex information that needs more areas to lay it out.

The reason that many columns are sometimes grouped into less is to give the designer flexibility. You are still conforming to the grid, but it give you the ability to layout a lot of information and many different ways you can layout a single page. The lower the number of columns in your design the least number of ways you can arrange the information.

there really are not any rules, just depends on the amount of information and the type of information that you have.

Usually in a magazine there are many different grids layouts, usually about 3 or 4. main articles, secondary articles and maybe the reoccurring features (i.e editors note, etc)

hope this helps

david

Thanks jayyy and david, what you have both written has been of great help and insight. What i get out of this is the versatility a grid offers with more columns used and also gives a structural hierarchy and constant format throughout.

What jayyy and dzobel said.

The grid, and the number of columns, should be dictated by the content of your publication. For example, you wouldn’t usually split fiction into six columns, just as you wouldn’t usually use one column for the section with letters from your readers... But then again, there are always exceptions.

In short, form should follow function. :-)

Find out how they are going to want to hack up the add space, for example, what is the smallest add they will sell. You might assume they will need a bit more flex than even they first imagine. If you design that in from the start they will love you for it later.

Thats an excellent point jupiterboy regarding the ad space, very good thinking.

Having spent years in the magazine business in a former life, I would recommend an odd number grid approach. 13 columns is quite a flexible grid. you can have three columns of four with an extra column for white space that can be inserted either on the outside, inside or between the columns. You can have 4 columns of three with that extra space, Two columns of six, again with that extra space to use as a layout element. Willi Kuntz was a big advocate of the 13 column grid, as is Will Hopkins of Hopkins/Baumann who worked with Kuntz.