driving me crazy.

I know they are both used often, I just can't put a finger on it...


Looks like Caslon 540 to me

initially I thought that as well, but its the J in particular is very different in Caslon.

logo.png: Hoefler Text (including the alternate ampersand and brackets )
Picture 3.png: Hoefler Text Italic

well done.

that's it! I was way off, never would have guessed.

we've got a type wizard here! Just wish I had an awesome hat to give you or something :)
in all seriousness, thanks much for your help.