Another triumph for Arial: ‘Kim Jong the Second’

joeclark
18.Oct.2009 3.09pm
joeclark's picture

Australian radio confuses I and lsomething Jesse Helms used to do.

“The problem lies in ABC News’s adoption of the Arial font for its news scripts [a bad idea right there]. Arial makes no distinction between a capital I and a small l. So Kim Jong-Il does look exactly like Kim Jong the Second.”

Fontgrube
19.Oct.2009 3.48am
Fontgrube's picture

It would have been the same with Helvetica or Akzidenz Grotesk.


joeclark
19.Oct.2009 5.39am
joeclark's picture

Neither of which is at the top of a Font menu on a Windows box.


Joe Clark
http://joeclark.org/


dezcom
19.Oct.2009 7.07am
dezcom's picture

Perhaps Arial should just stay "Under the Sea."

ChrisL


John Hudson
19.Oct.2009 11.03am
John Hudson's picture

I assumed ‘Kim Jong II’ referred to one of fearless leader's Bond-villainesque clones.


sii
19.Oct.2009 11.32am
sii's picture

In some fonts Kim could also be read as Kirn.


Fontgrube
19.Oct.2009 4.30pm
Fontgrube's picture

King Jom II - the son of his father.


russellm
19.Oct.2009 9.21pm
russellm's picture

Neither of which is at the top of a Font menu on a Windows box.

I predict, for the future of typography, the AAAAAAAA Andy's Towing Company school of nomenclature shall prevail.

-=®=-


sii
19.Oct.2009 9.56pm
sii's picture

On a clean install Windows (Windows 7 + Office) machine Arial is 11th, with Cambria, Calibri, and eight other "A" fonts ahead of it. Which does put it close to the top. Wonder where it would be on a similar out-of-box Mac install?


dezcom
19.Oct.2009 10.06pm
dezcom's picture

The Mac goes alphabetical

ChrisL


mili
20.Oct.2009 12.49am
mili's picture

A client of mine has decided to use capital L for liters to avoid confusion. It annoys me, but I sort of understand the reasons behind it.


capthaddock
20.Oct.2009 5.46am
capthaddock's picture

It's neither here nor there, but in Japan they still use ℓ for litres.


Ehague
20.Oct.2009 5.51am
Ehague's picture

This has a lot of do with context, though. You wouldn't say, for example, "Oh, I should make some line art in Adobe the-third-istrator."


joeclark
20.Oct.2009 11.04am
joeclark's picture

Si will keep in mind that every Windows user knows what Arial is; most think it’s “clean.” Some software defaults to its use. Si cannot seriously believe that more than a fraction of Windows users have enough knowledge to know what typefaces will harm them, as in the case of reading them aloud for an entire nation.

Hence, a familiar font name way up high in an alphabetical list will get used more.


Joe Clark
http://joeclark.org/


sii
20.Oct.2009 1.45pm
sii's picture

Obviously the underpaid chap who types up the script for the news anchor to read would not use Arial if they had a Mac, they would use whatever defaults Mac Office uses (Cambria?). I was just wondering how high up the list Arial falls on a typical Mac install. The age old question: Does it go up to 11?


dezcom
20.Oct.2009 3.56pm
dezcom's picture

ChrisL


sii
20.Oct.2009 5.14pm
sii's picture

Thanks Chris, although some of those entries stretch the definition of "alphabetic" :-)


dezcom
20.Oct.2009 8.20pm
dezcom's picture

I always hated that dingbat fonts get shown in their own "font" :-)

ChrisL


sii
20.Oct.2009 10.08pm
sii's picture

I think Mac has always had trouble with "symbol encoded" fonts, but better than the app that always treated font names containing "ding" as symbol fonts - "Wedding Script" got the shaft.


paragraph
21.Oct.2009 2.36am
paragraph's picture

But, Chris, what on earth is "ITC Galliard" doing between "Bauer" and "Bank"? Why two "Bauer Bodoni"? Did you fiddle the list for our amusement?


dezcom
21.Oct.2009 8.48am
dezcom's picture

"Did you fiddle the list for our amusement?"

The list is straight and unaltered. I don't even use a font activating utility.
Several of these fonts are old type one PostScript from back in the day when the bigger font vendors doctored names so that their corporate name did not affect the order--Adobe Garamond fell under "G" instead of "A". How "ITC" sneaks in in the "B" area makes no sense even with that. My guess is that the old way meets the new way and got fritzed in the process--that or it is a clue from the Knights of the Templar :-)

ChrisL


joeclark
21.Oct.2009 12.42pm
joeclark's picture

dezcom, that’s the MS Word list. Try a program that uses the system font list, like TextEdit or BBEdit.


Joe Clark
http://joeclark.org/


dezcom
21.Oct.2009 10.03pm
dezcom's picture

I know, Joe, that is what Si asked for above.

Here is the list from Textedit:

It seems all that goofy ordering above is a Microsoft Office issue.

ChrisL


sii
21.Oct.2009 10.33pm
sii's picture

Thanks Chris. I didn't suggest word to point out a font menu bug (although I’ve passed it on to the team) just thought it was likely the app used to develop the script for the news reader.


dezcom
22.Oct.2009 7.32am
dezcom's picture

That's OK, Si, at least now they know about it and may fix it.

ChrisL


DanGayle
22.Oct.2009 11.24am
DanGayle's picture


sii
22.Oct.2009 11.53am
sii's picture

sweet - did you make that? If so can I use it in a presentation I'm giving to some designers?

Cheers,Si


dezcom
22.Oct.2009 12.29pm
dezcom's picture

LOL!!! Good one, Dan!

ChrisL


paragraph
22.Oct.2009 6.10pm
paragraph's picture

Great stuff! Did you notice that this guy and the Iranian one both look like they still let their mother dress them?


DanGayle
23.Oct.2009 10.17am
DanGayle's picture

@Sii
Sure.


sii
23.Oct.2009 4.53pm
sii's picture

Thanks!


joeclark
24.Oct.2009 2.12pm
joeclark's picture

Very nice, Dan. But does it not work better in the accepted orthography, Kim Jong Il (no hyphen)?


Joe Clark
http://joeclark.org/


DanGayle
26.Oct.2009 8.39am
DanGayle's picture

Oh, my bad. I copy-pasted the text from your first post.


DanGayle
26.Oct.2009 8.43am
DanGayle's picture


dezcom
26.Oct.2009 8.52am
dezcom's picture

Is that the default word spacing, Dan? It looks too wide to me.

ChrisL


DanGayle
28.Oct.2009 8.47am
DanGayle's picture

Dang, you have a good eye. The first space is default. The second is an em width, specifically the width of the dash that I surgically removed because I didn't save the editable .psd.

Thomas Phinney gets all the credit as the font CSI dude, but I bet you could give him a run for his money!


dezcom
28.Oct.2009 11.45am
dezcom's picture

Old guys do it by eye :-)

ChrisL