New to Typophile? Accounts are free, and easy to set up.
Some questions for those who give critiques in that forum:
What makes a font sample useful for evaluation?
What sizes, layouts, arrangements give you the information you need on which to make informed commentary?
What statements do you hope to read when designers submit their designs for critique?
(Posted here since it's as close to a Forum Advice column as we have, though so far not very close at all.)