Often here on Typophile’s Critique forums are presented some beautiful typefaces.
As it happens, some of them gather a good deal of attention, while others will receive just a comment or two.
What I very rarely have seen happening is the designer coming back to the thread announcing the release of the font.
That said, here’s a short chronological list of fonts I would really like to see released in my lifetime:
Tierra Nueva, by Sebastian Nagel * RELEASED! (see first comment by Jens)
Epiphany, by Oleg Macujev
Ernestine, by Nina Stössinger
Ambicase Modern, by Craig Eliason
And, while to my knowledge it wasn’t ever submitted for critique, I would add the regular guest of the Type ID Board:
Noir, by Frode Helland