In the case of Scala, opening up the counters definitely adds to its intended use. Martin Majoor conceived the typeface at the end of the 1980s with low resolution output devices in mind (such as the 300 ppi desktop laser printer). Hence also the slab serifs. So, a kind of ink trapping, indeed — or rather “pixel trapping”.
But the open counter of P has a much older, palaeographic origin. (Deviate the “Roman” (= Old Italic / Western Greek) Π (Pi) from the Greek Ρ (Rho).) Cfr the Trajan capitals, most Garamont interpretations, Palatino, &c.
That doesn't work because -like any other small feature-
the gaps will be rendered differently depending on size,
closing entirely below a certain threshold*, completely
changing the character of the design.
* And this threshold will furthermore
vary depending on the character since
the size of the gap varies.
14 Feb 2012 — 3:43am
Calligraphic styling.
14 Feb 2012 — 4:09am
It's an extreme form of inktrapping.
It could improve colour of text.
It's a chirographic vestige.
14 Feb 2012 — 5:45am
Have a look at what Lirico does. The gaps fill in at text sizes.
14 Feb 2012 — 6:00am
It can be really pretty (reason enough, IMO).
14 Feb 2012 — 12:21pm
Also, it could deviate forms from
each other (for improved readability).
hhp
14 Feb 2012 — 1:47pm
The “a” in Eras and Friz Quadrata relates to an archaïc letter form.
Uncial perhaps?
14 Feb 2012 — 4:12pm
@hrant: do you refer to Scala or do you speak generally? Because I have doubts about that 6/9 pair, since it's basically the same rotated form.
14 Feb 2012 — 5:36pm
No, not Scala - just a general possibility.
hhp
18 Feb 2012 — 3:53am
In the case of Scala, opening up the counters definitely adds to its intended use. Martin Majoor conceived the typeface at the end of the 1980s with low resolution output devices in mind (such as the 300 ppi desktop laser printer). Hence also the slab serifs. So, a kind of ink trapping, indeed — or rather “pixel trapping”.
But the open counter of P has a much older, palaeographic origin. (Deviate the “Roman” (= Old Italic / Western Greek) Π (Pi) from the Greek Ρ (Rho).) Cfr the Trajan capitals, most Garamont interpretations, Palatino, &c.
18 Feb 2012 — 7:49am
That doesn't work because -like any other small feature-
the gaps will be rendered differently depending on size,
closing entirely below a certain threshold*, completely
changing the character of the design.
* And this threshold will furthermore
vary depending on the character since
the size of the gap varies.
hhp
18 Feb 2012 — 11:48am
Exactly. But with lighter/less pixels.